As Girl Scout cookie season sweeps across Vermont this winter and early spring, the annual tradition once again brings both sweet cravings and community support to the forefront for residents statewide. From Montpelier to Burlington and into the Green Mountains communities, buying cookies isn’t just about indulgence—it’s about helping local Girl Scouts build business, leadership, and life skills.
In Vermont, a state known for its tight-knit communities and seasonal celebrations, one classic flavor has long stood out: Tagalongs. But in 2026, Peanut Butter Patties—similar in flavor and increasingly available in some councils—are trending upward alongside this traditional favorite, reshaping local preferences even as other staples like Thin Mints and Samoas continue to delight cookie fans.
Tagalongs: A Classic Vermont Favorite
For years, Tagalongs—rich, chocolate-coated peanut butter cookies—have been a top pick among Vermont buyers. Their combination of crunchy cookie, creamy peanut butter, and smooth chocolate coating creates a flavor profile that resonates with both adults and children alike. The popularity of Tagalongs reflects a broader national trend: peanut butter and chocolate pairings consistently rank among the most beloved Girl Scout cookie varieties.
While Thin Mints remain a perennial best-seller nationwide and are widely stocked in Vermont, Tagalongs have become a go-to choice for many local cookie purchasers, often ranking among the top boxes snapped up at booths and online orders.
Peanut Butter Patties Gaining Ground in 2026
In 2026, an interesting shift is taking shape: Peanut Butter Patties—a cookie variety nearly identical to Tagalongs but offered under a different name by some bakery suppliers—are gaining traction among Vermont buyers. The growth in popularity of Peanut Butter Patties this season reflects increased availability and positive consumer response to subtle differences between the two peanut butter chocolate cookies.
Where Tagalongs dominate traditional sales, Peanut Butter Patties have emerged as a trend in regions where councils source cookies from bakeries offering that version of the peanut butter chocolate cookie. Vermont cookie lovers have been sampling both, and many note the similar yet distinct textures and flavors that make each worth tasting.
Other Favorites Still on the Table
Of course, Tagalongs and Peanut Butter Patties aren’t the only cookies Vermonters are buying. Thin Mints remain a staple on many shopping lists; their crisp chocolate wafers coated in minty chocolate offer a refreshing contrast to richer peanut butter and caramel options.
Samoas—also known in some regions as Caramel deLites—continue to be a beloved choice, with their gooey caramel, toasted coconut, and chocolate drizzle satisfying a different kind of sweet craving.
The 2026 cookie lineup also includes other classics and new options, with national Girl Scout offerings featuring flavors like the recently introduced Exploremores alongside traditional favorites such as Lemonades, Do-si-dos, and Trefoils.
Cookie Season: Sweet Fun and Real-World Skills
Beyond flavor preferences, the Girl Scout Cookie Program in Vermont serves as an important platform for personal development. Sales opportunities—whether at sidewalk booths outside local stores, community events, or through digital platforms—teach Scouts goal setting, financial literacy, customer engagement, and teamwork.
Proceeds from cookie sales stay local, funding troop activities, leadership programs, service projects, and outdoor experiences across Vermont’s Girl Scout councils. It’s this blend of entrepreneurial education and community investment that keeps residents coming back each year.
Vermont’s Evolving Cookie Culture
As 2026 progresses, Vermont’s Girl Scout cookie culture embraces both tradition and change. Tagalongs continue as a beloved local favorite, while Peanut Butter Patties steadily gain fans among peanut butter lovers exploring the full cookie lineup.
Whether chosen for nostalgia, flavor, or community support, Girl Scout cookies remain a sweet seasonal hallmark in Vermont—one that blends taste and purpose in every box sold.